Inter Partes Review Proceedings
PTAB Portal
IPR Case No(s):
U.S. Patent No.
9,669,069 (Use of a VEGF Antagonist to Treat Angiogenic Eye Disorders)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.; Celltrion Healthcare Co., Ltd.; Celltrion Healthcare USA, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
Y: Claims 1, 8-12
Claim Types Challenged Under § 102
Method of Treatment
§ 102 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1, 8-12
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Method of Treatment
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
Final Written Decision Issued
Y
Federal Circuit Appeal(s)
23-1395
IPR Status
Joined with IPR2021-00880; Final Written Decision (All Challenged Claims Unpatentable); Fed. Cir. Appeal Voluntarily Dismissed
U.S. Patent No.
9,254,338 (Use of a VEGF Antagonist to Treat Angiogenic Eye Disorders)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.; Celltrion Healthcare Co., Ltd.; Celltrion Healthcare USA, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
Y: Claims 1, 3-11, 13-14, 16-24, 26
Claim Types Challenged Under § 102
Method of Treatment
§ 102 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1, 3-11, 13-14, 16-24, 26
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Method of Treatment
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
Final Written Decision Issued
Y
Federal Circuit Appeal(s)
23-1396 (consolidated with lead appeal 23-1395)
IPR Status
Joined with IPR2021-00881; Final Written Decision (All Challenged Claims Unpatentable); Fed. Cir. Appeal Voluntarily Dismissed
U.S. Patent No.
10,464,992 (VEGF Antagonist Formulations Suitable for Intravitreal Administration)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.; Celltrion Healthcare Co., Ltd.; Celltrion Healthcare USA, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
Y: Claims 1-18
Claim Types Challenged Under § 102
Formulation
§ 102 Challenge Instituted
Y
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1-18
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Formulation
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
Y
Settled / Challenged Claims Disclaimed / Challenge Terminated
Y (Patent Owner Disclaimed All Challenged Claims After Institution Decision)
IPR Status
Adverse Judgment After Disclaimer
U.S. Patent No.
10,130,681 (Use of a VEGF Antagonist to Treat Angiogenic Eye Disorders)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.; Celltrion Healthcare Co., Ltd.; Celltrion Healthcare USA, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
Y: Claims 1, 3-11, 13-14, 16-24, 26
Claim Types Challenged Under § 102
Method of Treatment
§ 102 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1, 3-11, 13-14, 16-24, 26
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Method of Treatment
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
Final Written Decision Issued
y
Federal Circuit Appeal(s)
24-1564 (lead appeal, conslidated with 24-1567)
IPR Status
Joined with IPR2022-01225; Final Written Decision (All Challenged Claims Unpatentable); Federal Circuit Appeal Voluntarily Dismissed
U.S. Patent No.
10,888,601 (Use of a VEGF Antagonist to Treat Angiogenic Eye Disorders)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.; Celltrion Healthcare Co., Ltd.; Celltrion Healthcare USA, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
Y: Claims 1-9, 34-39, 41-43, 45
Claim Types Challenged Under § 102
Method of Treatment
§ 102 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1-9, 34-39, 41-43, 45
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Method of Treatment
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
Final Written Decision Issued
y
Federal Circuit Appeal(s)
24-1567 (consolidated with lead appeal 24-1564)
IPR Status
Joined with IPR2022-01226; Final Written Decision (All Challenged Claims Unpatentable); Federal Circuit Appeal Voluntarily Dismissed
U.S. Patent No.
10,406,226 (Method of Manufacturing VEGF Antagonist Fusion Proteins)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
N
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1-4
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Manufacturing
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
N
Settled / Challenged Claims Disclaimed / Challenge Terminated
Y (Patent Owner Disclaimed All Challenged Claims Prior to Institution Decision)
IPR Status
Institution Denied Due to Disclaimer of All Challenged Claims
U.S. Patent No.
11,253,572 (Use of a VEGF Antagonist to Treat Angiogenic Eye Disorders)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
Y: Claims 1-5, 8-11, 15-17, 20-21, 24, 26-30
Claim Types Challenged Under § 102
Method of Treatment
§ 102 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1-14, 16-23, 25-30
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Method of Treatment
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
Y (Joined)
Settled / Challenged Claims Disclaimed / Challenge Terminated
Y (Adverse Judgment Due to Disclaimer)
IPR Status
Joined with IPR2023-00884; Adverse Judgment After Institution Due to Disclaimer
U.S. Patent No.
11,084,865 (VEGF Antagonist Formulations Suitable for Intravitreal Administration)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
Y: Claims 1-17, 19-42, 44-50
Claim Types Challenged Under § 102
Formulation
§ 102 Challenge Instituted
Awaiting Institution Decision
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1-50
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Formulation
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
Awaiting Institution Decision
IPR Status
Awaiting Institution Decision
U.S. Patent No.
10,857,231 (Formulations of VEG Antagonist Fusion Proteins and Method of Manufacturing Them)
Patent Owner
Regeneron Pharmaceuticals, Inc.
Petitioner(s)
Celltrion, Inc.; Celltrion Healthcare Co., Ltd.; Celltrion Healthcare USA, Inc.
§ 102 Challenge
N
§ 103 challenge
Y: Claims 1-4, 6-11, 18-21, 27-32, 41-45, 58-59
Claim Types Challenged Under § 103
Formulation
§ 103 Challenge Instituted
N
IPR Status
Challenges Include Written Description (Claims 1-11, 17-21, 27-32, 41-53, 58-67), Enablement (Claims 1-11, 17-21, 27-32, 41-53, 58-67), and Indefiniteness (Claims 1-11, 17-21, 27-32, 41-53, 58-67); Institution Denied